This cute movie actress looks sweet and innocent but she’s far from it. Her last boyfriend was a rocker in a New York band who’d been around, but never met anyone like her. She laughed when she showed him all the stuff in her apartment that she had shoplifted. And he was astounded by her collection of pharmaceuticals. It got so he was afraid to go out with her- he never knew when she’d nick something and set off alarm bells in a store. She had enough pills in her purse to get them both locked up. That’s why the big bad rockstar left her .

39 Comments so far

1. By Anonymous
   On April 28, 2008 at

   winona?? or those freaky olsen twins

2. By Anonymous
   On April 28, 2008 at

   Kirsten Dunst

3. By Anonymous
   On April 29, 2008 at

   100% Winona Rider.
   Poor thing.

4. By Anonymous
   On April 29, 2008 at

   Hillary Duff?

5. By Tara
   On April 29, 2008 at

   WTF? Why would it be Winona? We all know shhe steals…it doesn’t have to be a blind item. I’m thinking Drew Barrymore and that Fabrizio (or whatever his name was) guy.

6. By Auntie Mabel
   On April 29, 2008 at

   It’s Hillary Duff, the Texas half-wit.

7. By Maddie
   On April 29, 2008 at

   Denise Richards (Richie Sambora)???

8. By Anonymous
   On April 29, 2008 at

   Emma Watson from Harry Potter and Johnny Borrell from Razorlight

9. By Anonymous
   On April 29, 2008 at

   The BI said NYC band, Johnny Borrell from Razorlight is based in London.

10. By Aimee
    On April 29, 2008 at

    THIS IS EASY.
    SCARLETT JOHANSSON! SHE LOOKS SWEET AND INNOCENT.
    SHE DATED BIG BAD AND GROUCHY JARED LETO WHO IS THE LEAD SINGER OF THE NEW YORK BAND 30 SECONDS TO MARS.
    HE BROKE OFF THE RELATIONSHIP BECAUSE “WE’RE TWO VERY DIFFERENT PEOPLE.”
    THERE YOU HAVE IT!

11. By Anonymous
    On April 29, 2008 at

    Scarlett sounds right. Wow, it would be a shocker.
    By the way, EWWW, the Olsen girls look like trolls. I wouldn’t call them “cute” in any way. It’s obvious they’re on something anyway.
    Gross.

12. By Anonymous
    On April 29, 2008 at

    CHRISTINA RICCI!!!

13. By Anonymous
    On April 29, 2008 at

    It’s not Hilary Duff because Good Charlotte is from Maryland not New York.
    I’m thinking whoever this person is she dated a guy named Nick or someone else in his band was named Nick because of the clue “he never knew when she would nick something.”

14. By Anonymous
    On April 29, 2008 at

    Christina Ricci never dated a rocker.
    Scarlett would make sense. She did have a long term relationship with Jared Leto and his band is based in New York.

15. By Brainy Smurfy
    On April 29, 2008 at

    ‘nic[k]‘ is a british expression akin to ‘pinch’ or ‘lift’, meaning to steal. I don’t think it refers to a name, but rather a possible nationality of the “rocker in a new york band”

16. By Anonymous
    On April 30, 2008 at

    Natalie Portman

17. By Anonymous
    On April 30, 2008 at

    Drew Barrymore!

18. By Anonymous
    On April 30, 2008 at

    Drew Barrymore isn’t sweet nor innocent.

19. By Amy
    On May 1, 2008 at

    Do you EVER give the answers to these “whodunits”? That would be only fair!

20. By Anonymous
    On May 1, 2008 at

    Kirsten Dunst just got out of rehab. I think it was her.

21. By Anonymous
    On May 1, 2008 at

    Kirsten isn’t “cute”
    When I think “cute” I think Natalie Portman, Scarlett Johansson, Reese Witherspoon. They’re not “beautiful” they’re wholesome-looking adorable.
    Kirsten didn’t date a NYC rocker, she dated a British rocker!

22. By Anonymous
    On May 1, 2008 at

    JC didn’t say is was a NYC rocker. She said a NYC based rocker. And nick is English slang.
    I think it’s Dunst.

23. By Anonymous
    On May 1, 2008 at

    This is totally Drew Barrymore and Fabrizio Morretti(?).

24. By Anonymous
    On May 1, 2008 at

    Misha & Cisco

25. By Anonymous
    On May 1, 2008 at

    Misha & Cisco

26. By notty
    On May 1, 2008 at

    lauren graham

27. By Anonymous
    On May 1, 2008 at

    Kirsten’s ex isn’t in a New York band!
    His band Razorlight is based in London.
    It could be Cameron Diaz, she had a long term relationship with Jared Leto and his band is based in NYC.
    Cameron makes more sense than Drew Barrymore. I don’t consider Fabrizio “big and bad.”

28. By Kat
    On May 3, 2008 at

    Kirsten Dunst, for sure.

29. By Anonymous
    On May 3, 2008 at

    Let’s face it. All these broads fit the MO!

30. By rosie
    On May 4, 2008 at

    denise richards.

31. By Anonymous
    On May 4, 2008 at

    Don’t know if it’s Kristen Dunst, but she recently made a pass at my 21-year old son at a movie studio party!
    She was a little tipsy at the time. He turned her down because he prefers brunette girls.

32. By caliblonde
    On May 4, 2008 at

    Mischa would make sense – she’s British!

33. By Anonymous
    On May 4, 2008 at

    kate hudson?

34. By Anonymous
    On May 5, 2008 at

    Mischa Barton does not look sweet nor is she innocent. Her ex-boyfriend Cisco Adler is in a LA band. The BI hints that the rocker in question is from an NYC band

35. By Anonymous
    On May 5, 2008 at

    Is it Jessica Simpson?

36. By Liz
    On May 6, 2008 at

    Renee Zellwegger?
    Before the debaucle with Kenny Chesney she was with Jack White of The White Stripes for a really long time wasn’t she???

37. By Anonymous
    On May 7, 2008 at

    Jack White’s band is from Detroit.
    I really think it’s Cameron Diaz. She and Jared Leto dated for a long time. BI’s don’t point fingers at the obvious suspects like Winona, Kirsten, Drew or Mischa. We all know about their drug problems. Not shocking

38. By Anonymous
    On August 14, 2008 at

    winona ryder:groupie,drug and
    stealer!

39. By Mimi
    On August 15, 2008 at

    Thanks for the reveal Janet.

39 Responses to “”