Just as we predicted last July, Joel Madden and Hilary Duff ‘s romance was headed for disaster. And it’s MORE than their eight year age difference. (Joel was Hilary’s first real romance) Money was the big stumbling block. Their incomes are at opposite ends of the spectrum – Hilary is earning millions with her music and acting and Joel’s band Good Charlotte is struggling to make a comeback. And of course, Hilary is out of town most of the time working somewhere, and long separations ignite suspicions. Joel even had Hilary’s bodyguard reporting back to him on her activities. Finally they realized that although they still care about each other, they just weren’t as happy as they used to be, and they called it a day. Still, we suspect a lot of texting will go on before it’s really over.


Posted by Janet on November 30, 2006

There are 23 Comments.  TELL ME WHAT YOU THINK!

23 Comments so far

  1. By Anonymous
    On November 30, 2006 at

    I think even though they seemed like opposites, they we were really cute together. And hopefully will get back together

  2. By Anonymous
    On November 30, 2006 at

    pee pee poo

  3. By Anonymous
    On November 30, 2006 at

    His band is lame. He seems like a creep. When he and his brother were on Punk’d they were total asses to some guy that was in an accident and needed help. Sure it was fake, but he was more concerned with his dumb assed Range Rover than a bleeding man. Guys can’t handle when the girl earns more cash money! See ya!

  4. By Vicki T
    On November 30, 2006 at

    So, why do so many people on this site want to be ‘anonymous’?

  5. By jackie
    On November 30, 2006 at

    FINALLY. Joel can do better than that poser, anyway.

  6. By Hedda Bopper
    On November 30, 2006 at

    What has she done to her face? Didnt she used to be so pretty?Those huge new fake teeth and nose job have made her look more like her ugly sister.No matter whom she dates,she still looks strange these days.Hey joel,give me a call I”ll show you my good charlette…..OYE VEY

  7. By Anonymous
    On November 30, 2006 at

    He and his fatty brother are no talent douche bags. Make shitty music and chase underage pussy who don’t know any better yet. Good Riddance to Good Charlotte.

  8. By cutegirl
    On December 1, 2006 at

    i think they should overcome all the problems in their relationship and support each other…

  9. By Jen
    On December 1, 2006 at

    didn’t he start dating her when she was 16? umm, that’s illegal! and gross…
    also, she got her teeth fixed. they look MUCH better!

  10. By Anonymous
    On December 1, 2006 at

    I wish them both the best of luck.

  11. By Anonymous
    On December 2, 2006 at

    No comment from me. She’s too young to settle down anyway, and Good Charlotte really, really sucks. What a crappy band.

  12. By florance
    On December 2, 2006 at

    hey hilary have you ever heard of jojo. hum not only is she a better singer than you but shes going with a 38 year old guy named fredy ado and shes only 16 and when she started going with him she excepted him even if he was older than her and today jojo is still going with him to shes the one who really loves a guy unlike you bitch hilary who only went with him for attetion oh come on if you were really concern with his age in the first place why in the hell did you go with joel he was better of whithout you preppy slut duff whos gave it up to everyone but joel and one more thing when jojo first saw freddy ado she gave him a big chance and dident care what people siad about it she was just like look i love him hes in my life and i dont care about are age wow jojo is more smater than you hilary dork your just a poser and always will be poor joel you never loved him if thats the case buy

  13. By siobhan
    On December 2, 2006 at

    looks like hilary have lost a lot of fans because of the breakup i used to be a huge joel fan but now i dont like either of them because they just sold out, i meen have you seen the tiny dress hilary is wearing in her new video and joel was dating someone 8 years younger that jusst not right and for awile was actually illegal.

  14. By Raquel
    On December 11, 2006 at

    Im so glad!!
    Hilary-i hate
    Joel-i hate
    but i still think hil can do better!! It’s not just the 8 year difference, It’s cause if he has bodyguards reporting back to him about her actions, can you say paranoid!
    He obviously doesn’t trust her. Hil deserves someone who trusts her even if she is on the other side of the world with hot guys. Lmao!

  15. By Anonymous
    On December 13, 2006 at


  16. By shelly
    On December 16, 2006 at

    they just want us to think hilary is a omg im so pretty, an fake and a version please hilary not a good girl she was probly down and dirty with joel and gave it up to him all the time people are crazy who thinks hilary duff is a version p.s joel madden pop her cherry bye

  17. By Anonymous
    On December 28, 2006 at

    i think they are both cool dont reply back

  18. By Anonymous
    On December 29, 2006 at

    Joel should not of made hilary dump him!!! She was nice to him, even though he had his issues! She doesn’t deserve such crap!! I can’t believe Joel had the heart to try to cheat on Hilary! Hilary is a smart punk girl, but doesnt feel like she has to try to show it all the time.

  19. By kayla
    On March 13, 2007 at

    hilary you could have done way better that freak joel is just a poser that doesnt even care about you i think you could have done way better than that fing jerk honestly he should be kissing your dam feet right now because YOU are the one who is making all of that dam money that he never make ever because his dumb ass fucking band is stupid thanx for listening byez.

  20. By kayla
    On March 13, 2007 at

    hil i still think you made an awsome choice to dump that fucking dumb ass jerk because he was cheating on you and for all that money that u were making just to make him fucking happy holy shit i would have dumped him a while ago because he wasnt helping you much was he byez
    P.S:you go gurl

  21. By Alyssa
    On October 24, 2009 at

    I like hilary.
    I like joel.
    I thought they were adorable together. :]
    Hilary duff has amazing music.
    And Good Charlotte is really good.

    And who cares if she got her teeth done?
    what celebrity hasnt?

    On April 19, 2014 at

    Church, chaplain, type of playbook format not screenplay format, fantasy movie ideas,

    (ACHILLIES, ATHENA, ALEXIES, ALBA, BOUNCE are talking to the school board about the little guys being slavery driven with school work today. They have just flown in on their quads yes flying quads. The Raptors they just flew in on are to show the little guys “a thing or two about a thing or two.” When they get to the board there is a room full of students wanting the board to do away with their homework assignments. They want the schools to be taught like “Adult School.”)

    (Music ACHILLIES walks in with a radio to play Avril Lavignes “Here’s To Never Growing Up.”)
    ACHILLIES you guys are the board of schools that are responsible for the little guys class parties, homework, class work, projects work oh just the work. We get we might not be the best choice for speaking for the little guys being how in the family we have “Rangers Apprentice” and “Assassins Creed” as our casted characters for future movies in the Heavens sort-a-speak. We are just here to pass the idea to the schools and then to the little guys that it is okay to get fat and not do homework.

    ATHENA little guys should not do any homework or any types of school work along with tests. We get work when we grows up we want to go to the Naval Academy to be a Marines Jetfighter Pilot so we get work. Little guys do not know that they should not have to do any type of work in, out of class or take tests. Tests do not measure what you know. What you know is what you can say not what you can answer on a test. The nerds that get good grades on tests might not know for example how to date for the smaller guys how to be around girls. Maybe the little guys are fat because they do too much nerdy homework.

    ALEXIES classes should be easy, learning should be done easy enough for people to understand and learn. Teachers are busy with a type of confusion, talking over little guys heads or so. Little guys sometimes do not pick up on what is being taught. Maybe teachers need a few classes on how to be around the girls.

    ALBA “when you’re too cool for skool” they say you do not want to go to dates or dances with the ugly girls. Anyways boyz do not realize that on some planets boyz get home from skool and do not have to talk to their sister or girls the whole time while their out of skool playing video games. School is too much for everybody. Teachers are being taught to tell students to cheat and school looks to be the ugly girl present day. In class all the students should have to do is kick back and listen but the skeptics say they should work. We think they should work for a living sucking down sodas and playing on the jungle gyms or so.

    BOUNCE little dudes need to be allowed to play. Right now the little guys have 0 time to play outside with other little dudes or so. The little dudes have been attacked by the bads and the bads have them in “time out” from playing video games and such. Skeptics are telling the schools students need work but students need “time outs” sometimes too. Yo critics, skeptics the little dudes need time to party.

    ACHILLIES schools are run by people saying little guys need more class work, class time, classes. Would a good person be there saying all these things to increase the workloads. Would a good person do any of these things to the school systems. These people have little claim to school but the boards are letting them increase class work and such. The bads are saying dudes are getting smarter but they are just as dumb as they ever were. Had to say it that way for you all to “feel me.” Now while you’re “feeling me” all students should have less class time to go out and play and to not be slaves of school sort-a speak.

    “Heavens Raiders, Heavens Black Knights, Heavens White Knights, Heavens Green Berets”

    # 1 in high school # 1 fighter # 1 genius # 1 comedian

    Achillies Zenith Howe Anonymous
    Geniuses Social Scientist Psychiatrist
    Psychologist Film Military Scientist
    Anthropologist Movies Sarcasm

  23. By the best skin care products
    On April 29, 2014 at

    Hello my friend! I want to say that this post is amazing, great written and include approximately all significant infos.
    I’d like to look extra posts like this .

    Also visit my site … the best skin care products


XHTML: You can use these tags: <a href="" title=""> <abbr title=""> <acronym title=""> <b> <blockquote cite=""> <cite> <code> <del datetime=""> <em> <i> <q cite=""> <s> <strike> <strong>

By submitting a comment here you grant Janet Charlton's Hollywood a perpetual license to reproduce your words and name/web site in attribution. Inappropriate comments will be removed at admin's discretion.

Follow Janet

blog advertising is good for you


Custom Search
© 2006-2012. All rights reserved. Janet Charlton's Hollywood.
Web Development by Strange, Funny, Weird, Dark | Private Policy

blog advertising is good for you


  • Blind Item: America’s Sweetheart Battling A Drug Addiction?


    One of America’s Sweethearts is battling a serious drug addiction- not hers, but her best friend’s. Through the years these two have been stuck to one another like white on rice and her fame rubbed off on her pal. They’ve been roomies, have worked together on set, and even launched a business venture together. But all that success has come with a price. After years of being sober, the less famous friend has fallen HARD off the wagon and our gal doesn’t know what to do. She’s hosted an intervention, hired an addiction specialist, and even threatened to end the friendship, but nothing seems to work. What’s a girl to do?


Janet Charlton’s Hollywood Blog Archives

Previously Posted Items

April 2018
« Mar